Skip to main content

ProShares Financial ETFs versus Real Estate ETFs - which should you own?

In looking at the constituent holdings of the ProShares Ultra Financials ETF (UYG) I noticed that there seemed to be a good number of REITS included.

To investigate further, I took the holdings of the ProShares Ultra Real Estate ETF (URE) and did a direct compare to the holdings of UYG.

To my surprise, every single one of the holdings in the Ultra Real Estate ETF, comprising a variety of 80 different REITs, was also included in the Ultra Financials.

Relative performance --

It is interesting to see how real estate underperformed the combined financials until March of 2008 when the situation turned around and financials became the one that underperformed.


Chart of UYG vs. URE
In the first part of the chart, you can see URE begin to weaken as the news about troubles in the real estate sector began to take a toll. During this time, the idea that the problems in real estate wouldn't spill over into the rest of the financial sector or the general economy was still in vogue. By last October reality began to set in and as URE continued its severe down-trend, UYG began to drop at a faster rate. By March of this year, UYG overtook URE on the down side as bank stocks crumbled. That situation continues today.

For the ultra-short ETFs, SKF and SRS, the charts would, of course, be the inverse.

Conclusion --

To review, the Financial ETF holds a diversified mix of banks, brokers and investment houses, mutual fund management companies, commercial and consumer lenders, insurance companies, etc. as well as REITS.

The Real Estate ETF holds all the same REITs as found in the Financial ETF and nothing else. The REITs do fall into a number of different categories including health care, apartments, retail, hotels, etc.

The primary conclusion is that it may not make sense to simultaneously own both UYG and URE. If you want to invest in diversified financials, you can buy UYG and get the holdings of URE as part of the package.

Similarly, it may not make sense to simultaneously own both of the ProShares Ultra-Short ETFs, the Ultra-Short Financials (SKF) and Ultra-Short Real Estate (SRS). If you want to bet against a diversified basket of financial stocks, buy SKF and get the holdings of SRS as part of that package.

As always there is an exception to the rule. If an investor wishes to overweight the real estate sector beyond what the long or short Financial ETFs offer then it is reasonable to add some of the Real Estate ETF to the investment mix.

On the other hand, if an investor wants to concentrate solely on REITs, clearly the ultra-long URE or the ultra-short SRS are the appropriate ETFs.

Disclosure: none

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Brazil - in a bubble or on a roll?

A couple of years ago, no one recognized the real estate bubble even though it was under everyone's nose. Now, analysts and bloggers are seeing bubbles everywhere they look. One of them, they say is in Brazil whose Bovespa stock market index has doubled in the last 12 months. Does the bubble accusation hold water? I don't think so and here are 7 reasons why Brazil is by no means a bubble economy: Exports have held up over the past year thanks to demand from China for Brazil's soya exports and iron ore. This was helped by the the Brazilian government's drive to improve trade links with Asia and Africa. Export diversification, spurred by a more active trade policy and increased focus on "south-south" trade under current president Lula, helped mitigate the decline in demand from OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development) countries A "sensible" economic framework has been in place since the 1990's. This has included inflation

Thursday Bounce: Trend Busters, Swing Signals and Trend Leaders for July 9, 2009

This is a quick post to announce that we have published Thursday's Trend Leaders, Swing Signals and Trend Busters at Alert HQ . All are based on daily data. Today we have the following: 72 Swing Signals -- A couple of days ago we had 35 signals, today we have twice as many. Happily, we now have 65 BUY signals, a mere 4 SELL Signals plus 3 Strong BUYs. Whoo-hoo! 56 Trend Leaders , all in strong up-trends according to Aroon, MACD and DMI. There are 18 new stocks that made today's list and 60 that fell off Tuesday's list. 48 Trend Busters of which 5 are BUY signals and 43 are SELL signals The view from Alert HQ -- Talk about mixed signals. If you look at our Swing Signals list you would think the market was in the middle of a big bounce. BUY signals are swamping the SELL signals and we even have a few Strong BUYs. Yes, there's a good sprinkling of tech stocks and tech ETFs but the distribution is pretty broad-based with a good number of different sectors represented, eve

Unlock Stock Market Profits - Key #1

This is the first in an ongoing series of articles where I discuss what I feel are keys to successful investing. It is based on a post that provides a summary of the ten keys that individual investors should use to identify profitable stock trades. ( Click here to read the original post ) There are two basic steps to investing. First, you need to find stocks that seem to have some potential. Then you have to determine whether these stocks are actually good investments. There are many stocks that at first glance look interesting, but further research reveals that there are too many negatives to warrant taking a position. This first post in the series starts at the beginning: getting good investment ideas. Key #1: If something special is happening to a stock, it will be reflected in some kind of unusual activity in the markets. As individual investors, we will never be the first to know; however, unusual activity can be an early sign that allows us to follow the Wall Street professional